On November 4, 2024, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in United States ex rel. Heath v. Wisconsin Bell. The question presented is whether reimbursement requests submitted to the private corporation administering the E-rate program are FCA “claims.” Under the statute’s definition of “claim,” the answer hinges on whether the Government “provides” the requested money. All funding for the program, established by Congress, comes from private contributions. Yet where private contributors incur debts owed to the corporation, the United States Treasury collects those debts and transmits the funds to the corporation. The Court’s questioning suggests that the Court will conclude that the Government “provides” at least the money that it disburses to the corporation. The Court, however, appeared reluctant to make any determination as to whether the Government “provides” the other money paid to the corporation—all private contributions paid directly to the private corporation.

(more…)