Day

August 10, 2016

10 August 2016

Ninth Circuit Cautions Against Allowing Relators to Assert Expansive Claims Based Only On Specific Incidents of Alleged Wrongdoing

In a ruling earlier this week, the Ninth Circuit emphasized the demanding standard Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 9(b)’s particularity requirement imposes on qui tam relators alleging fraud, particularly when seeking to pursue an expansive scope of claims based on limited information.  In United States ex rel. Driscoll v. Todd Spencer M.D. Medical Group, Inc., No. 13-17624 (9th Cir. Aug. 9, 2016), a former radiologist employed by the defendant medical group, alleged that the group and its principal violated the FCA by submitting claims to Medicare for “unnecessary CT scans” and, separately, by “unbundling” single procedures into multiple claims to “increase billings artificially.”  Id. (slip op. at 3).  The relator alleged that this conduct persisted for at period of several years, from at least 2007 to 2010, and perhaps longer.  United States ex rel. Driscoll v. Todd Spencer M.D. Med. Grp., Inc., No. 1:11-cv-1776, 2013 WL 6243858, *5 (E.D. Cal. Dec. 3, 2013).  After allowing the relator one opportunity to amend his complaint, the district court dismissed the first amended complaint with prejudice, concluding that these allegations were insufficiently specific to withstand Rule 9(b)’s particularity requirement.  Id.

(more…)

SHARE
EmailShare
XSLT Plugin by BMI Calculator