June 28, 2016

28 June 2016

First Circuit Upholds Dismissal of FCA Claims with Prejudice Taking Middle-Ground Approach to Particularity Requirement

The First Circuit, in United States ex rel. Garcia v. Novartis AG, upheld the dismissal of a FCA claim with prejudice against Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation, Novartis Corporation, Genentech, Inc. and Roche Holdings, Inc. (collectively “Defendants”) on the basis that the complaint did not include sufficient specific allegations regarding the who, what, where, and when of the fraud to satisfy Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 9(b).  In so doing, the First Circuit appears to have taken a fact-specific middle-ground approach to the Rule 9(b) particularity standard, rather than wholly following either side of the Circuit split on the particularity standard.


XSLT Plugin by BMI Calculator