Day

July 6, 2015

06 July 2015

In Long Running Tuomey Saga, the Fourth Circuit Provides a Roadmap For Constitutional Challenges to Excessive FCA Awards

On July 2, 2015, the Fourth Circuit affirmed a $237 million verdict against Tuomey Hospital following a retrial in the government’s long-running effort to pursue alleged violations of the Stark law. (See our previous posts on the case here and here). As we previously reported, in 2013 in U.S. ex rel. Gosselin v. Bunk, the Fourth Circuit acknowledged that FCA awards are subject to Eighth Amendment scrutiny, but it rejected the constitutional challenge in that case without providing any concrete standards against which the constitutionality of an award in any particular case could be measured. In the more recent Tuomey opinion, the Fourth Circuit again rejected Eighth Amendment and Due Process challenges to the constitutionality of the award. However, the opinion provides a roadmap for future challengers that suggests that constitutional challenges could find traction in cases in which there is a significant discrepancy between per-claim damages and penalties.

(more…)

SHARE
EmailShare
06 July 2015

District Court Refuses to Reconsider Bifurcation of Trial between Proof of Falsity and Other FCA Elements

Posted by Kristin Graham Koehler, Monica Groat, and Marina Romani (Summer Associate)

As we have previously discussed on this blog, a court in the Northern District of Alabama last month granted AseraCare’s motion to bifurcate its trial. On June 25, 2015, the court refused the Government’s request to reconsider that decision.

(more…)

SHARE
EmailShare
XSLT Plugin by BMI Calculator