Jun 282013

HHS Touts FCA Settlement in Spring 2013 Semiannual Report to Congress

mmorrissey@sidley.com
, , , , ,

The Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”) Office of Inspector General (“OIG”) recently reported expected recoveries of approximately $3.8 billion for the first half of fiscal year 2013, which included last year’s $1.5 billion global settlement with pharmaceutical company Abbott Laboratories to resolve False Claims Act violations.

In its recently released Semiannual Report to Congress (“Semiannual Report”), which covered the period of October 1, 2012, through March 31, 2013, the HHS OIG touted its global settlement with Abbott as well as other settlements and criminal actions. The Semiannual Report is produced to inform Congress and the HHS Secretary of the OIG’s notable findings, recommendations, and activities over specific six-month periods.

The Semiannual Report highlighted the five-year Corporate Integrity Agreement with Abbott, described as “a global criminal, civil, and administrative settlement,” that the HHS OIG originally entered into with the pharmaceutical company in May 2012 “to resolve allegations that it violated the False Claims Act by improperly marketing and promoting the drug Depakote for uses not approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), including the treatment of aggression and agitation in elderly dementia patients and the treatment of schizophrenia.”

Of the $3.8 billion that the HHS OIG expected to recover, over $521 million was from audit receivables and approximately $3.28 billion was from investigative receivables. Other activity highlighted in the Semiannual Report included:

  • The exclusions of 1,661 individuals and entities from participation in federal health care programs;
  • The filing of 484 criminal actions against individuals or entities that engaged in crimes against HHS programs;
  • And 240 civil actions, including false claims and unjust-enrichment lawsuits filed in federal district court, civil monetary penalties settlements, and administrative recoveries related to provider self-disclosure matters.

The HHS OIG has said that historically, approximately 80 percent of its resources have been directed to Medicare and Medicaid-related work. In the Semiannual Report, it reported that efforts by the government’s Medicare Fraud Strike Force teams led to charges against 148 individuals or entities, 139 criminal actions, and $193.7 million in investigative receivables.

mmorrissey@sidley.com

mmorrissey@sidley.com

You might also like
DOJ Reaches Settlement with Laboratory Over Commission-Based Compensation Arrangements with Independent Contractors, Medical Necessity

Earlier this month, the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”) announced a $5.9 million FCA settlement resolving allegations that Genotox Laboratories Ltd., a toxicology and pharmacogenetics testing laboratory: 1) violated the Anti-Kickback Statute (“AKS”), and thereby caused the submission of false claims, through commission-based compensation arrangements with its independent contractors, and 2) submitted claims to federal healthcare programs for unnecessary drug tests.  In parallel proceedings, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of Texas and Genotox entered into an eighteen-month Deferred Prosecution Agreement to resolve a criminal investigation into the same conduct.  The settlement highlights DOJ’s ongoing interest in pursuing independent contractor arrangements that do not fit within a safe harbor to the AKS, where such relationships are also accompanied by conduct that traditionally attracts enforcement scrutiny, such as submission of claims for medically unnecessary services.

Second Circuit Leaves Open Novel Legal Theory that Flawed AI is a “Worthless Service”

In a decision issued last week, the Second Circuit was faced with the novel legal theory that use of flawed artificial intelligence systems can constitute a “worthless service” for purposes of FCA liability.  See Doe v. eviCore Healthcare MSI, LLC, No. 22-530-CV, 2023 WL 2249577 (2d Cir. Feb. 28, 2023).  The Second Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal for failure to satisfy the heightened Rule 9(b) pleading standard but did not reach the merits, leaving open the question of whether such a theory is viable under the FCA.

FY 2022 FCA Recovery Statistics Show Increase in DOJ and Whistleblower Actions, Which Continue to Target the Healthcare and Life Sciences Industries

On February 7, 2023, Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General, Brian M. Boynton, announced that the Civil Division recovered over $2.2 billion in settlements and judgments under the False Claims Act (“FCA”) for fiscal year 2022.  Detailed statistics on FCA recoveries from 1986 through FY 2022 are available here.